India ranked 26th in 'getting electricity' to do business and not universal electricity for its population, as widely understood following Power Minister Piyush Goyal’s comments on World Bank’s assessment of the country’s electrification efforts, a BOOM fact check revealed.
On May 14, the Press Trust of India (PTI) reported Goyal saying India had climbed up to the 26th spot in World Bank's electricity accessibility rankings in the current year, from being ranked 99 in 2014.
While 'electricity accessibility' and 'getting electricity' sound interchangeable, getting electricity is a specific parameter in the World Bank's Doing Business (DB) rankings.
“Our ranking has improved to 26 positions from 99. So, it is truly very redeeming feature and satisfying for me that Prime Minister’s vision particularly to take electricity to every home, particularly to make electricity access very easy, particularly to make energy affordable is being furthered very rapidly,” Goyal was reported to have said.
A day later, MyGovIndia tweeted the following info-graphic which the minister retweeted.
India soars high in World Bank's Electricity Accessibility Ranking #TransformingIndia https://t.co/cjKSFPNdM9 pic.twitter.com/O7Mm15thxv
— MyGovIndia (@mygovindia) May 16, 2017
MyGovIndia is a government-backed citizen engagement platform on social media.
An email to MyGovIndia from BOOM seeking a clarification of data went unanswered.
BOOM tried to reach the minister and his office directly on Twitter but did not get a response.
@mygovindia @PiyushGoyalOffc @PiyushGoyal @PiyushGoyal Sir, we are trying to reach your office with regards to this data. Whom can we contact? Thanks in advance.
— BOOM FactCheck (@boomlive_in) May 17, 2017
‘GETTING ELECTRICITY’ IS NOT THE SAME AS ‘ELECTRICITY ACCESS’
BOOM found that the 2017 ranking of 26 cited by the minister and the info-graphic is that of the ‘Getting Electricity’ indicator of the World Bank’s Doing Business Report, 2017.
A clarification from the World Bank to BOOM helps explain the difference.
“Indeed, India got ranked #26 on the Getting Electricity indicator in the Doing Business 2017 report. But the Getting Electricity indicator does not measure universal electricity access for all of the population in the country, and rankings from different years cannot be directly compared because of the methodology change from one year to another,” Elena Karaban, Senior Communication Officer, South Asia, World Bank, wrote.
“The Getting Electricity indicator does not measure electricity accessibility of the general population. For instance, the affordability of tariffs or percentage of households connected to the grid are not measured,” Karaban citing a clarification from the World Bank’s Doing Business team, wrote.
WORLD BANK MEASURES ‘POWER FOR BUSINESS’ AND NOT ‘POWER FOR ALL’
In its Doing Business rankings, the World Bank only measures the ease at which a local business can obtain a formal electricity connection.
The government’s usage of the line ‘power for all’ obfuscates its meaning as it leads the reader to believe it means power for everyone in the literal sense. Moreover, ‘Power For All’ is a government initiative that includes industries, commercial entities and households.
The Power For All initiative was launched by the Centre in June 2014 to provide 24X7 electricity to all at an affordable price by 2018 – 2019. The objectives of which include:
- Ensure reliable 24X7 supply of electricity to all consumers which include industries and commercial entities and households.
- Supply adequate electricity to farmers for irrigation which shall be for 8-10 hours
- Electrify all households by 2018-2019
WHERE THE GOVERNMENT CONTRADICTS ITSELF
BOOM found a notice dated May 4, 2017 on the power ministry’s official website quoting similar data but a side-by-side comparison with MyGovIndia’s info-graphic shows how the two contradict each other.
Unlike the info-graphic, the notice specifies that the rankings are for ‘getting electricity’ in the doing business report. They also differ with respect to the base year used in comparison (2014 in the info-graphic and 2015 in the notice).
(Left: Info-graphic shared by MyGovIndia. Right: Power ministry’s notice on its website)
WORLD BANK DISCOURAGES COMPARING RANKINGS OF DIFFERENT YEARS
The World Bank’s Doing Business (DB) team says since the inception of the annual DB report there have been several methodology expansions and as a result the scope of what is being measured by an indicator today is broader than what was measured in earlier reports.
Therefore a historical year-over-year comparison of India’s ranking in either ‘getting electricity’ or the overall DB ranking would not be right as individual indicators of what is being measured have undergone changes over the years.
India ranked 130 among 190 countries on World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business rankings for 2017 released last year. (2016)
Since coming to power in May 2014, Narendra Modi’s government has made an aggressive bid to improve India’s DB ranking as it wants to seal its image as a business-friendly government in the eyes of global investors.
WHERE THE POWER MINISTRY GETS IT RIGHT
The World Bank acknowledged strides made by the Modi government in its electrification efforts.
“The past three years’ major reforms have included reforms in the Getting Electricity topic. The utilities in both Mumbai and Delhi have actively reduced the delays and processes required for firms to obtain new electricity connections. In Delhi, it took 138 days to obtain a new connection in 2013, compared to 45 days today,” World Bank’s Doing Business team, said.